Colchester vs Cheltenham prediction & probabilities (2026-09-19)

League Two

Colchester vs Cheltenham Cards

2026-09-19 · 15:00
Cards49.1%Over 3.5 cards

Result

Colchester 1-1 Cheltenham
7 yellow cards (Colchester 3, Cheltenham 4)
1 red cards (Colchester 1, Cheltenham 0)
Under 3.5No

We called Under 3.5 at 50.9% and it missed (7 in the match). We called No at 89.3% and it missed (1 in the match).

Best predictionOver 3.5 cards · 49.1%Close to a coin-flip, barely a lean. Calibrated, not a tip.
49%

model probability

ConvictionLean

Expert AI analysis

The headline read is Over 3.5 cards at 49.1%, its strongest read on the Cards market. Across the lines, the model goes from 70.3% for over 2.5 to 16.0% for over 5.5, with over 3.5 the closest line to a coin-flip at 49.1%. Head to head on cards, Cheltenham are the model’s pick to pick up more cards at 47.7%, with a level count at 21.4%. Calibrated against real results, we show the read, not a sure thing.

Cards (bookings)

Over 2.570.3%

Over 3.549.1%

Over 4.529.9%

Over 5.516.0%

Total cards, every line

Line Over Under
2.5 cards 70.3% 29.7%
3.5 cards 49.1% 50.9%
4.5 cards 29.9% 70.1%
5.5 cards 16.0% 84.0%

Who picks up more cards

Colchester30.9%

Level21.4%

★ ModelCheltenham47.7%

Team card lines

Colchester over 1.5

47.7%

Colchester over 2.5

21.8%

Cheltenham over 1.5

60.1%

Cheltenham over 2.5

33.0%

Card handicap

Colchester line Colchester Cheltenham
-1.5 14.8% 85.2%
-0.5 30.9% 69.1%
+0.5 52.3% 47.7%
+1.5 72.6% 27.4%

Red card

Any red card10.7%

Colchester red card1.4%

Cheltenham red card9.4%

Fouls

Line Over Under
20.5 fouls 70.4% 29.6%
22.5 fouls 55.6% 44.5%
24.5 fouls 40.4% 59.6%

This season (2026/27)

0.7Colchester cards per game
10.3Colchester fouls per game
1.8Cheltenham cards per game
11.8Cheltenham fouls per game

The discipline market is less analysed than goals, these are the model total-booking probabilities for Colchester vs Cheltenham. The model leans toward Cheltenham for the most cards.

In-depth analysis

We publish the model, not a sure thing. We score every call against the result after the match.

49.1%Over 3.5 cards
10.7%Any red card
47.7%Most cards: Cheltenham
47.7%Colchester over 1.5 cards
60.1%Cheltenham over 1.5 cards
55.6%Over 22.5 fouls

Split by side, Colchester over 1.5 cards sits at 47.7% and Cheltenham at 60.1%. A red card for either side is rated at 10.7% (Colchester 1.4%, Cheltenham 9.4%). This season Colchester have averaged 0.7 cards a game and Cheltenham 1.8.

Model lenses

The same numbers read in different ways by one model. These are not separate tipsters, and none of them is a tip.

The CalibratorRaw model read: 49.1% on Cards, graded against real out-of-sample results, no odds attached.
The FlashpointAny red card is rated at 10.7%, unlikely, and priced as such.
The DisciplinarianCheltenham are the pick to collect more cards at 47.7%, bookings follow the side defending under pressure.
The Line SetterThe fairest total line is 3.5 cards: over sits at 49.1%, the closest to a coin-flip on the ladder.

FAQ

How many cards in Colchester vs Cheltenham?
Before kickoff, the model rated over 3.5 total cards at 49.1% for Colchester vs Cheltenham.

Will there be a red card in Colchester vs Cheltenham?
Before kickoff, the model rated a red card for either side at 10.7%.

Which team will pick up more cards in Colchester vs Cheltenham?
Before kickoff, the model rated Cheltenham to pick up more cards at 47.7%, with a level count at 21.4%.

How is this probability calculated?
We fit a goals and markets model (Dixon-Coles plus an xG strength model and an ensemble) on real match data, then calibrate the output against out-of-sample results. It is a calibrated model probability, not an odds-derived tip.

Is this a betting tip?
No – these are calibrated model probabilities, graded against real results. We publish our full track record, including the misses, and never claim to beat the closing market.

Cards accuracy

How our Cards calls have actually done, each one scored against the real result on matches the model had never seen.

61.4%Best Cards call, hit rate
0.0223Calibration error
50,461Matches graded

In 10,197 matches we rated like this one (40–50%), Cards actually happened 48.5% of the time.

Predictions & track record updated 22 Sep 2026. See the full, dated track record →

Our last 10 Cards calls

Our most recent Cards calls, each one scored against the result. The model had never seen these matches when it made them. Green means we got it right, red means we got it wrong, and the number is how sure we were.

✗ 50.8%✗ 52.3%✗ 57.6%✓ 51.7%✓ 52.7%✗ 52.0%✗ 53.2%✓ 71.8%✓ 57.0%✗ 62.5%
4 of 10 recent calls hit.
Bournemouth vs Liverpool2026-09-20Over 3.5 50.8%Miss
Leeds vs Crystal Palace2026-09-20Under 3.5 52.3%Miss
Manchester City vs Sunderland2026-09-20Over 3.5 57.6%Miss
Fulham vs Manchester United2026-09-20Under 3.5 51.7%Hit
Leverkusen vs RB Leipzig2026-09-20Over 3.5 52.7%Hit

More League Two, Cards

All Cards predictions →

Related

Model probabilities, calibration-graded, not a tip. We publish our track record, including the misses. 18+. For information only, not betting advice. If gambling is a problem, visit BeGambleAware.